Page 1 of 1

FPL was intermittently offline

Posted: 12/14/2014
by lisi891
My FPL was connected to linksys SP2 ATA, but it was offline once or twice a month. Each time I have to restart the ATA by unpluging power cord, and the ATA was online again.

It seems registration failure causes the problem, and ATA could not connect server automatically after each offline.

Any solution will be appreciated.

Re: FPL was intermittently offline

Posted: 12/14/2014
by bridonca
What do you have for a router, and modem? Not quite sure the exact model of the Linksys ATA, but I am confident, that like most Cisco VOIP gear, it is unforgiving if there is a even a slight misconfiguration. My first guess would be the router is starting to forget where to route the packets. Depending on the router, you might have to manually forward RTP ports from the router to the ATA. Let me know what you got for gear

Re: FPL was intermittently offline

Posted: 12/14/2014
by lisi891
Thanks for you reply.

I did not understand that I had used other IP phone for many years, and there was never such an issue.

When I used I talk BB, I never configured any routers no matter where I moved. Internet speed did affect voice quality of I talk BB, but there was never offline issue.

Re: FPL was intermittently offline

Posted: 12/14/2014
by bridonca
I have had gear get dementia. Works great for years, then forgets things. Might be an issue on Fongo's side, but seems unlikely. I am blaming your gear, because registration issues are purely gear related. Only time Fongo would give you issues is if your registration time is less than 3600 seconds. Anything less and Fongo considers that your device is hammering the Fongo network, and the Fongo network kicks the offending gear off the Fongo network for a period of time.

Re: FPL was intermittently offline

Posted: 12/14/2014
by lisi891
The registration of my ATA is 3600s.

Re: FPL was intermittently offline

Posted: 12/15/2014
by bridonca
I deleted your picture. No one needs to know your personal information. If someone finds out your phone number, they probably have access to your SIP account.

Your Cisco ATA seems to be working as well as expected. As I said before, this is a horrible ATA when it comes to fault recovery. Other than it's established shortcomings, I do not think there is anything wrong with the ATA.

I should have been more clear in saying that I suspect that it is your router that is slowly losing it's mind, and forwarding ports from the router to the ATA makes it easier on the router, because it no longer has to guess where to send packets. You need to specifically forward RTP ports form the router to the ATA, I forget exactly what the RTP ports are on the Cisco, but find out on your ATA, and forward them. What do you have for a router again?

Routers generally are not 100% when it comes to routing SIP packets, but it seems you had a good run until now. If the forwarding ports do not work, it might be time to look for a new router, preferably one with the option to flash to DD-WRT.

Re: FPL was intermittently offline

Posted: 01/01/2015
by hxcanada
I have similar issue since last week. By the way, I have been with FPL for several month without any issue.

At the very beginning, I also thought it was glitch in ATA. I am using Cisco SPA112. After unplugged / plugged the power, the FPL LED was still off. I logged in to ATA admin web page, and tried voip2.freephoneline.ca. Still didn't work. I thought it was an issue from FPL. After search the Forum, and I didn't find similar complain. I thought it might be caused by my ISP (Teksavvy). Then, I tried free SIP software (Zoiper), and I found it is working. It means that the ports was not blocked by my ISP, and the most important, the FPL is up and running. Then, I restart my router (TD-W8961ND), and immediately, the FPL LED became on. I realized that my router is the culprit.

I thought it was just a glitch, and the problem was solved after I restart the router. However, the problem came back again while I was away for the previous 3 days. When I came back today, I found the FPL LED is off again. I restarted the router again, and the FPL LED is on again. It is so annoying that my phone line got cut off while I was not at home.

Do you (Bridonca) or does anyone know how to configure my router or my ATA to make it stable? It just happened since last week, and it had been running perfect without any issue for the previous several months. Do you know why?

Thanks a lot in advance.

Re: FPL was intermittently offline

Posted: 01/01/2015
by hxcanada
By the way, I did not use my old router (TD-W8960N) for long. For the past several months, I have always been using my current router (TD-W8961ND).

Re: FPL was intermittently offline

Posted: 01/01/2015
by hxcanada
I am using default settings for both my router and my ATA. The "Register Expires" of my ATA is also 3600.

Re: FPL was intermittently offline

Posted: 01/02/2015
by bridonca
As I said before, Cisco ATA devices are not very fault tolerant. Hybrid router/modem combination usually are horrid routers, and your modems seem to be on that category. You would likely not have this problem if you got a better ATA like an Obihai product, which tend to to a better job in working around the issues a cruddy router creates.

I have never dealt with tplink modems, but their routers usually are awful, so I will go with that. You might be able to forward RTP ports from the modem/router to the ATA, but again, I do not have confidence the tplink can do that reliably. Is there a newer firmware update? Sometimes there is a fix in the newer firmware.

If I wanted stable VOIP, I would go this route. I would put the modem in bridge mode, and get a proper router, preferably one that can be flashed with DD-WRT. I would suspect your SIP VOIP problems would go away after that.

Re: FPL was intermittently offline

Posted: 01/04/2015
by hxcanada
Thanks. I believe it also related to some FPL VOIP servers or settings, because TekTalk VOIP from Teksavvy connected to the other port of my SPA112 is not affected, which is also using default parameters.

Re: FPL was intermittently offline

Posted: 01/05/2015
by Liptonbrisk
hxcanada wrote:I am using default settings for both my router and my ATA. The "Register Expires" of my ATA is also 3600.

It's not just "register expires" that's important.

A. Registration Interval:
3600 seconds (1 hour)

B. Registration Expiry:
3600 seconds (1 hour)

C. Failed Registration Re-Try Interval:
120 seconds


visit http://support.freephoneline.ca/entries ... redentials